IMPORTANT NOTE: the distinctions between rose species are best understood as broad generalizations, with
ample room for overlap, intergradation, and exceptions. See
Historical Background and
Taxonomic Decision-making for a general overview of the taxonomic challenges presented by roses. Note also that prickles are best observed
on middle and upper parts of the stem; prickles at the base of the plant are often significantly denser, straighter, and/or thicker than described here.
1. Leaflets < 1 cm long, incised ± halfway to midvein; hips densely bristly; distinctive native of chaparral in extreme southern California and Baja California . . . Rosa minutifolia [subg. Hesperhodos]
1' Leaflets > 1 cm long, toothed < 1/4 to midvein; hips glabrous, hairy, or stalked-glandular [subg. Rosa]
3. Stipules not fringed; styles many, brush-like, only protruding ca. 1 mm; petals 1--2.5 cm long; flowers few [Sect. Caninae]
4' Leaves and sepals glandular, fragrant; terminal leaflet generally elliptic to ± widely obovate . . . R. eglanteria L.
2' Sepals without prominent lateral lobes; styles not protruding, hypanthial opening filled with brushlike stigmas; stem generally ± grayish or brownish; prickles curved to straight, thick-based to slender; petals always pink (except for possible albinos); native species
5' Sepals persistent or only irregularly breaking off; flowering hip generally 3--7 mm wide; pedicel various (glabrous, hairy, or glandular), 0.5--3 cm wide; flowers solitary to several; petals generally 10--25 mm long; pistils generally > 10; leaflets variable, rarely more than 3 per side; prickles variable
7' Hip generally glabrous, rarely with a few stalked glands at base; other features variable
8' Prickles generally abundant, both slender and thick-based intermixed; terminal leaflet generally ± elliptic; flowers general several; native stands of Monterey pine on central California coast . . . Rosa pinetorum
9' Prickles generally ± thick-based and flattened, otherwise variable; other features variable; west side of the Sierra Nevada
10' Prickles generally not curved, often only moderately flattened, few to many, often pale and contrasting with dark stem; pedicels glabrous to glandular but not hairy; hip glabrous or glandular but not hairy, most often globose; sepals generally with glands, the tip prominent, generally > sepal-body
11' Hip generally 3--6 mm wide at flowering, ± 10 mm wide at maturity; flowers generally clustered, 2--10; sepal-tips not toothed; leaflets, pedicels, and hips never glandular; prickles mostly paired at nodes, sometimes nearly absent; northwestern California . . . Rosa pisocarpa
top of page
6' Open shrubs or thickets, generally > 5 dm tall, often > 10 dm; leaflet-margins single- or double-toothed, glandless or glandular; leaflet-apex not truncate; prickles variable [Sect. Cinnamomeae]
back to main rose page